Grandmaster:
I have no problem with that. All he is saying is that Halachic reality trumps actual reality. Just like Migu doesn’t necessarily require that the person would actually lie, Halacha decides that he has Nemanus (Or Koach HaTaiyna). Or if you don’t understand like the Chasam Sofer (pashtus), that “Besulim” is defined by Chazal, not the actual presence of the physical Besulim. This is the opinion of Rav Belsky as well. Others hold one should be Machmir for both sides.
Interesting that the other person to bring in this “Rabbi Breil” was The Joseph, no?