Grubber yung -“it means there are sources who regard this as borderline heresy (Reb Aaron Kotler zt”l, for example, related in the name of the Vilner Gaon that this is not the correct view).”
After reading all the posts above it seems that this Shitta is more of a Daas Yochid than the other.
“Such a questionable concept should not be sold by ANYONE as a dovor poshut, without giving the slightest mention of those who vehemently disagree.”
Since this is what they hold, they aren’t required to bring down the other Shittos.
“I personally think that the Ami should stick to recipes, and leave sensitive topics in Judaism to everyone’s respective rebbeim.”
You are entitled to your opinion, but they aren’t going to listen to you because that’s not what sells mags!
If you feel that they aren’t up to your Haskafa standards -you should definitely not buy/read it.
Coming here and trying to make an argument that they are Chazar Treif won’t work because they have at least one Shitta to be Someach on!
And btw, I have never bought this mag in my life.