Reply To: REPLY TO mdd ABOUT CALLING GIRLS BY 1ST NAME

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee REPLY TO mdd ABOUT CALLING GIRLS BY 1ST NAME Reply To: REPLY TO mdd ABOUT CALLING GIRLS BY 1ST NAME

#810719
Health
Participant

therealmgama -“it is STRONGLY RECOMMENDED that he and other male workers address her only by her official name”

“Rav Falk is very clear, and careful to specify when he is writing a halacha, and when he is writing a recommendation.”

“You, mdd, replied that it is not assur and her reaction was extreme.”

Noone has pointed this out yet – but not only don’t you refute mdd’s claim, you actually help prove it. I’m sure you read what you wrote before you posted it. R. Falk strongly recommends that your relative shouldn’t have been called by her first name. Granted, they did something wrong. You yourself admit that R. Falk doesn’t hold this is Ossur! So she quit her job because s/o else didn’t keep a Chumra. Even if they called her a nickname which he says is Ossur, all she had to do is say my name is Chaya, not Chayala. I most definitely agree with mdd’s post that her reaction was very extreme!