Reply To: Copying CDs

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Copying CDs Reply To: Copying CDs

#839552
marbehshalom
Participant

well to those of you who may have learned the sugya of devorim shebilev in kedushin…..

the gemorrah discusses a case where one sold his possesions with the intent of making aliyah to ey. The reshonim learn that the fellow did mention to his friends that that his intent is for aliyah, for otherwise its poshut he can not be mevatel a mechirah on such a claim. Never the less since he did not stipulate b’shas mechirah, we say words in heart are not words. so my arguement that i would like to present to the choshuver coffee drinkers is: that since it is not mentioned in tranaction but merely stating on the jacket theus the rental is buttul.

BTW dass yochid – what is your level of halacha education?

p.s. i think rabbi yahoo levin shlita from lkwd has issued a shtikel torah on this inyan years ago. if anyone knows where its printed please let me know.