Reply To: Winter Vacation & Minyan Problem- your opinion please

Thank you everybody for your feedback. The scenario I presented is actually an argument I had with someone over Shabbos. In my opinion he is wrong and I wanted to get the opinions of the CR membership.

The only point I made up was the Yartzeit argument. I thought it might add a twist.

FYI- I asked my Rov and he said that Halachically you can not remove or stop someone from davening with a minyan unless they are disrupting the minyan. However, he said it is not so pashut that one can just join the minyan.