I am happy to see that Hakoton had no answer on what I wrote in rebuttal to his fatuous arguments. Still waiting.
As far as all thid talk and discussion who was what and when did how ,it is TOTALLY IRRELEVANT. Eretz yisroel exists today as medinat Israel and-nothwithstanding the evil extremists wish- will exist forever, IY”H.
To argue historical issues on what might have been, how would it have been is sterile discussion because no one knows.
If hakoton and health are so concerned about Eretz ysroel ,let them go live there and demonstrate with their NK brethren. Then, at least, I would have some respect for them (as long as they don’t don nazi garb)