I would agree that the heading should have been written different, with more feelings towards another yid, especially when the subject still maintains his innocence, and there is no evidence against him except for the word of the owner of the store, so this whole story may be lashon horah, hotzoas shem ra, plus a very extreme headline against an observant yid.
BUT, talking about stupidity as boycott etc. on the awesome most precious yiddishe website YWN is ridiculous, its from the only famous popular sights covering positive news on charedi yidden almost as much as negative, while other populr sites may totally ignore many positive stories of ehrliche yidden, only bringing out the bad side copying the frum hating Israeki news sites with provocative captions.
Yeshiva world wouls bring stories that show the misery that a lot charedim are going thru by the chiloni charedi hating neighbors.
And, as a result YWN has the biggest clientele of heimishe yidden, versus some other famous/infamous sites that have many non yidden or half yidden posting there.