Reply To: Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk

Home Forums Yom Tov Purim Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk Reply To: Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk

#866321
popa_bar_abba
Participant

Itche: Just for you I pulled up my handy dandy bar ilan and looked it up.

Here are my results:

The following poskim speak on this halacha, and don’t say that any sort of alcohol is preferable to any other:

Mechaber

Rema

Mishna berura (and beur halacha)

Taz

Magen Avraham

Shaarei Teshuva

Chayei adom (explains it is because nes was with drinking wine, but doesn’t say that the only mitzva is davka grape wine as opposed to apple wine or barleywine or beer.)

Levush

Elya rabba (elya zuta says to eat and drink the first night also)

aruch hashulchan

I haven’t found anyone yet who insists it must be grape wine only.