Reply To: Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk

Home Forums Yom Tov Purim Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk Reply To: Problem Being Unable to Consume Much Alcohol – And Can't Get Drunk

#866347
popa_bar_abba
Participant

the Gemoroh never says Chayav inish “lehishtaker” – it says l’ivsumai. This is clearly reference to a state of exaltation, not the loss of one’s mind. The pirushim in ad delo yoda do not include anything bordering on danger.

By danger, you mean like shechting your friend who is an amora?

Is our drinking only for the mitzvah, where we do not lose focus from the true simcha of nais Purim, or are we at least partially capitalizing on Purim for our annual “legitimized” opportunity to get drunk?

Do we only eat meals on shabbos to honor shabbos, or do we like eating it? Do we like lighting chanuka candles? Who cares if we like it–chazal say to do it and I do.