Reply To: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us Reply To: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us

#868755
Health
Participant

000646 -“Health,

The 4th grade education thing is not mentioned in the book. She said it in an interview.”

So the fact that she only lies in public interviews and repeats false rumors that even Anti-Frum publications like the Jewish week claim are false, are irrevelant – such a person would never lie in her book?

“Would you mind pointing out which facts in her book are not true?”

From the poster below:

“They were discussing the truthfullness of what she said and a teacher who had taught with her said:

In her book she said she never wore makeup until her wedding. But I taught with her when she was single, and she wore makeup every single day.”

“Can you explain how you know her book is “full of falsehoods” if you have not read it?”

I never said “I know”. Don’t put words in my mouth! I’ll repeat what I posted -“If I’d want to waste my time and read her trash -I’m sure I’d find many falsehoods!”

“Or do you just assume anything that writes something negative about your way of life is false?”

Actually I don’t assume anything in life. I look at things as much as humanly possible in an objective way.

It’s obvious you can’t!

I’ll repeat what I posted above:

“For you to keep posting how accurate her book is, even though it’s quite obviously just another antisemitic book, you must have an agenda. What is it? Do you hate all Frum Jews or just Satmar?”

Every piece of mag trash out there has some truth. The Enquirer nowadays has lots of true statements -that’s because they kept getting sued until they learned their lesson. As matter of fact people say that in every lie there has to be some truth. IMHO, there are more true statements in the Enquirer, the Star, the Globe, etc. than probably in her book. So the fact that her book is selling like hot cakes -means to me that the same people who buy these supermarket trash mags are now buying a book.

And if you tell me -there are some intelligent people buying this book who would never buy these trash mags -then they must be buying it because they are virile antisemities!