hello99: I can find you a whole list of poskim who hold cholov stam is treif. Are you going to stop advising people they can rely on Rav Moshe as a result? I can list you who paskens artificial insemination leads to mamzeirus. Must everyone follow the most stringent opinion despite those poskim who hold otherwise? Rav’s Leff and Shapiro aren’t unique in this position. There is no reason people can’t follow their shitta. Even IF it is a minority opinion, the world isn’t required to universally disregard a minority opinion to follow a ruling that has more contemporary poskim. And when being mlamed zchus ex post facto, we certainly can ascribe their actions to being in adherence to the shittas that are permissive.
Menu