Reply To: chicken

June 25, 2012 2:09 am at 2:09 am #881011

pcoz

Member

In your comparison to avno sakino umasao do you mean to say that seeing as the av here seems to be esh which always has a koach acher meurav bo therefore there is no requirement to have an original maaseh mazik?

i.e. would you agree that for other other avos nezikin you do need a maaseh hezek for a shomer to be chayav?