Reply To: Would you choose army or kollel?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Would you choose army or kollel? Reply To: Would you choose army or kollel?

#887049
☕ DaasYochid ☕
Participant

you can try yout utmost in your reasoning (this is why I called it a pilpul) but paying kollel jungeleit is ZEDAKAH !</em.

Wolf would have a field day with your logic.

people have not accepted this idea that everyone should learn at the expense of the tsibbur.

Many have, and the rest need to be educated. At the very least, you can stop being part of the problem, now that you’ve seen r’ Moshe’s teshuva and that you were wrong l’halacha. (I’m assuming you didn’t mean “everyone” literally.)

popa- you are quoting a daas jochid in R’Nehoroi-look at the gemoro berochos 35B.

It is the Gemara’s conclusion.

Also, popa- you are wrong in your percentages. You forgot to count the tens of thousands of young bachurim who are learning. Don’t they count??

I don’t know where anyone gets their numbers from, but it’s clear that R’ Moshe wanted many married men to receive stipends.

After all, we seem to be the adults in the room.

I am disappointed that you have resorted to bolstering your argument by calling those who disagree with you children.