Shlishi: He still has Haskamos from R’ Shmuel Kamenetzky. The Gedolim who put one (maybe two) of his books in Cherem (I won’t say who) never even saw what he says in them because they don’t speak English. He was never given a chance to discuss or explain what he wrote. For all we know, the Gedolim who put him in Cherem were entirely lied to about what he published or were told something vague like “He says Chazal is wrong”, which isn’t what he says at all. And just because I disagree with something doesn’t make it an “untruth”, unless you respect my opinion that much. 🙂
Menu