Beethoven wasn’t born deaf, he went deaf after his hearing began to deteriorate in his late twenties. He certainly wasn’t tone deaf. And besides, he wrote down his music. It sounds kinda weird that a tone deaf person would be composing music and people would be carefully inclining their ears toward the person to make out the tune. Not very realistic.
Also, of course it’s theoretically possible for anyone to put together the right notes to make up a song that is coherent. The same way it’s theoretically possible for my four year old sister to put together the right words for the president’s State of the Union address. But there’s a reason he hires professionals to help him and not my four year old sister. Same with everything.
Oomis – +1