PBO is correct, of course.
Evolution is, at best, a theory, and most likely trash.
Regardless, Rav Elchonon Wasserman HY”D said it is clear, to anyone who is not an idiot, that Hashem created the world.
I saw a great point, at a different Torah web site that, during the 6 days of creation, Hashem created a developed world, not a barren one, as we can see from the pesukim. This includes the Earth, vegetation and animals, not to mention Adam and Chava.
So any carbon dating or any other methods that scientists use, for whatever those methods are or aren’t worth, will anyways not reflect the actual age of the world since the world was already dated at creation.