Reply To: About the RCA, I do shudder.

147: Edit: I just read a secular news story about that, and it described the wedding people as “youths”. But, if it was a rav, then I should not have said “dude”.

zdad: If they assume Rav Yosef was misled by his advisors, then that is still no reason to say such things about him.

Feif: The letter was not signed by any of those rabbonim. Meanwhile, the RCA has about 1000 members–I surely don’t attribute this letter to all of them. In fact, regarding the rabbonim you mention, we might collectively wonder why the letter was not signed by them, and might easily infer the answer.

So yes, your post is a cute retort that if they cannot bash for bashing, then how can I bash for bashing for bashing, but it is misplaced.