Reply To: About the RCA, I do shudder.

PBA: If you were the only person, then you’d probably be wrong in your assumption that what you’re doing is standing up for Kavod HaTorah.

Probably.

But that’s irrelevant. This discussion, as is, should have died after it was clear the letter never should have been made public.

I don’t agree. For two reasons:

1. It shouldn’t have been said in private either.

2. Where is the apology and retraction? There is none. You know why? Because their constituency doesn’t care. And then they wonder why their congregants don’t listen to what they say.