Sam2:Please show me an example in halocho where one Bais Din can invalidate another’s psak. “ein davar kazeh”. No such thing exists. We don’t have a sanhedrin today and every Bais Din is autonomous. You may not want to accept that ruling but it is inconceivable- and I bet you , never mentioned in choshen mishpot, that a Bais can invalidate another Bais Din’s psak. We are not talking here about a Nossih or a Bais Din Godol that made a manifest error- as mentioned in Torah and Horiyos- but the case before Rabbi Sherman was whether the Bais Din of Rav Druckman did a correct conversion. Even if he had his doubts, it is the height of “chutzpah’ to invalidate the Bais Din and all its rulings.
Menu