Reply To: About the Government of Israel, I do shudder

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee About the Government of Israel, I do shudder Reply To: About the Government of Israel, I do shudder

#964199
☕ DaasYochid ☕
Participant

if you still maintain wahtever explanation you concoct

The gemara means exactly what Sam2 said it does.

Do you really think I was saying that the rule is we are always machmir? You can’t bring proof from specific cases in which we are meikil; of course we are sometimes meikil. We are also sometimes machmir.

Bringing “koach d’heteira odif” to support being meikil in general is wrong, and dangerous. In fact, as Sam and I have pointed out, that gemara actually indicates that unless one is certain of his position, he must be machmir.