Charlie: No. What is intellectually dishonest is to use Rabbi Shapiro’s book to be Mattir Apikorsus across the board. What Farber said is Apikorsus L’chulei Alma. That is true regardless of whether or not debate also exists about other Ikkarim according to the Rambam. He ran himself out of Orthodoxy when he said that the Torah wasn’t Min Hashamayim.
Menu