Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › In Chad Gadya – HKBH was “wrong” › Reply To: In Chad Gadya – HKBH was “wrong”
April 23, 2019 2:11 pm at 2:11 pm
#1718685
etzhar – “You have started from the wrong place.
We start with the line that G-d is right.”
No, that doesn’t make sense.
You don’t start with the “effect” and then the “cause”. or with the “onesh” (punishment) and then the “avaira” (wrongdoing).
The order must be “cause” and “effect”, wrongdoing followed by punishment or mitzva followed by s’char (reward).
Besides, if at the end you must say that “thats where the Emunah kicks in”, then it can be applied no matter where you start. If we conclude that HKBH is “wrong”, simply apply the “thats where the Emunah kicks in.”! What do you gain by reading the Chad Gadya backwards?!