Applesauce on latkes is better than sour cream: Prove me wrong.

Home Forums Yom Tov Chanukah Applesauce on latkes is better than sour cream: Prove me wrong.

Viewing 28 posts - 51 through 78 (of 78 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1638409
    CTLAWYER
    Participant

    @Milhouse
    My 30 year old daughter is a carbohydrate queen.
    She loves mashed potato sandwiches and would eat a latke sandwich

    #1638427
    ZionGate
    Participant

    Milhouse,
    A POTATO latke?
    Reminds me of when in the yeshiva lunchroom I put some mashed potatoes in between bread slices.
    The rebbe on lunchroom duty that day saw me eating it, walked over to me and quoted the gemarah ” Haneh tipshoi d’Bavli d’uchleh nahama B’nahama .”
    To this day, I don’t know what I did wrong.

    #1638518
    cmberzon
    Participant

    ziongate
    hope you’re misquoting lunchroom Rebbi
    Bavli Tipsha’ee ate two slices of bread nothing inside
    if your Lelafet is mashed potatoes rather than peanut butter then go for ir
    but its not a replacement for a hot dripping latke

    #1638526
    ZionGate
    Participant

    Nope, wasn’t misquoting.
    Maybe that’s why he was lunchroom rebbe.

    #1638546
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    In the modern world the statement can mean not to eat carbohydrates without protein but other carbohydrates
    as we make a brocho on fruit because it does not go with bread. Similarky potatoes does not go with bread.

    #1638548
    cmberzon
    Participant

    ziongate
    tartey lrayusa
    lunchroom rebbie ( bet he wore a frock)
    and didn’t respect mashed potatoes, a main sidedish in yeshiva lunchroom ( i bet even withspinach)

    #1638558
    ZionGate
    Participant

    laskern,
    Could be that’s what the rebbe meant.

    cmburzon… Lol… No frock… He was actually a very nice man.
    Mashed potatoes & peanut butter were indeed the main staples, not sidedishes . …Along with the unforgettable noodles& cheese treats.

    #1638549
    Milhouse
    Participant

    ZionGate, my father says the same thing. To him sandwiches are only for making a meal portable. He doesn’t get the whole idea of eating sandwiches when you’re at home and can eat the bread and other things separately.

    cmberzon, ZionGate had it right. The “stupid Bavlim” did not eat two pieces of bread together! That really would be stupid. They ate bread dipped in Kutach, which is a fermented sauce made mostly from yoghurt, stale bread, and salt . (Think of soy sauce, which is mostly soy beans, wheat, and salt.) This of course makes perfect sense, but in EY they made fun of it.

    #1638601
    cmberzon
    Participant

    Milhouse
    what’s the hesitancy of describing Bavliim as real stupid?
    Also, simple words are solely nahama with nahama without even kutach that would enhance taste.
    the korech of seder night seems to point to a sandwich enabling someone to eat on the run etc.
    Re latkes the original subject: a great latke perhaps doesn’t need anything to enhance its taste.maybe a few napkins to keep hands dry

    #1639011
    Milhouse
    Participant

    cmberzon, “Hani Bavli Tipsho’i” refers to the Bavli habit of eating bread with kutach, or with porridge or other grain-based foods. NOT with actual bread. Whoever told you it meant literally two identical pieces of bread was falsifying pshat in gemoroh

    #1639017
    CTLAWYER
    Participant

    Tonight we had very special latkes, and yes they were served with applesauce on the side.
    We are fortunate to have a separate Pesach kitchen on our second floor. Every Chanukah we follow a very old tradition of using the Pesach kitchen (In Europe they would kasher for Pesach) to prepare a roast Goose for a Chanukah dinner, and render jars of goose schmaltz for Pesach. We use enough of the goose schmaltz to fry one night’s worth of latkes for the family. Truly a unique taste…………..

    #1639139
    cmberzon
    Participant

    Milhouse
    always thought peshat inביצה טז was the popular style in bavel was two slices of bread real lowlife Chazal compares inserting or dipping into bread without enhancing the bread as also being tipshut. a mashed potato sandwich sounds peculiar unless drenched in ketchup and fried onions. re a latke sandwich חבל on the latke

    #1639165
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    cmberzon, I think you are missing a comma as you don’t want to say on chazal the expression lowlife.

    #1639574
    Milhouse
    Participant

    cmberzon, how can you possibly have thought the gemora in Beitza is talking about two pieces of bread, when it explicitly says it is talking about eating bread with porridge?
    ודייסא לא מלפתא דאמר ר׳ זירא הני בבלאי טיפשאי דאכלי נהמא בנהמא

    #1639593
    Freddyfish
    Participant

    Id prefer if we can call them potato pancakes and by the way applesauce on top is king!!

    #1639623
    Redneck
    Participant

    Helooooo! Guys it’s peanut butter al the way!!!

    #1811355
    RebbeDebbie
    Participant

    Since the traditional/proper way to make latkes involves shmaltz, you cannot serve them with sour cream and thus must use applesauce.

    Eating latkes with sour cream is rejecting tradition in the same manner as someone switching from nusach Sefard to nusach Ashkenaz.

    #1811488

    RD: Where did you know that it is the ” traditional/proper way to make latkes involves shmaltz” ? Maybe it was always made with Shemen Zayis?

    #1811489
    catch yourself
    Participant

    There is a מנהג to eat fried food on חנוכה as a זכר to the נס of the פך שמן. Eating food fried in anything but oil, then would be a less than optimal way of observing this מנהג.

    Those who made their Latkes with schmaltz (probably a relatively recent innovation, which has been, like so many others, artificially and incorrectly invested with the aura of “Mesora”), therefore, are the ones who are in the wrong.

    The analogy to switching from Nusach Sefard to Nusach Ashkenaz, therefore, is quite appropriate, since Nusach Ashkenaz is the one with a real Mesorah, and Nusach Sefard is a relatively recent innovation that does not even pretend to be based on a Mesorah going back to אנשי כנסת הגדולה. This is why Rav Moshe Feinstein ruled that one may switch to from Nusach Sefard to Nusach Ashkenaz but not the other way.

    There is also a מנהג to eat dairy foods on חנוכה as a זכר to the נס of the מלחמה (and the story of יהודית).

    It is proper to combine these two מנהיגים so as to express the idea (put forth by the Maharal and many others) that the purpose of the נס פך השמן was to demonstrate the miraculous nature of the military victory.

    Applesauce, on the other hand, has absolutely no basis in מנהגי חנוכה and is only being eaten for תאוה, which is part of the legacy of the Yevanim.

    It is probably for this reason that Hashem ברוב חסדו וטובו made it that Latkes taste so much better with sour cream than with applesauce (and, in fact, even plain is better than with applesauce).

    #1811529
    knaidlach
    Participant

    על טעם וריח אין להתווכח!

    #1811531
    RebbeDebbie
    Participant

    lowerourtuition11210: “Where did you know that it is the ” traditional/proper way to make latkes involves shmaltz” ?”

    My Bubbe’s handwritten recipes!

    #1811532
    knaidlach
    Participant

    על טעם וריח
    אין להתווכח.
    ואיבעית אימא let me first taste both and only after eating about 5 of each i can tell you. (yes you guessed right, i love latkes).

    #1811816

    And my grandmothers recipe was with oil not shmaltz.

    #1812009
    banjobob
    Participant

    you have not lived until you eat latkes with melted cheese and ketchup. prove me wrong 😉

    #1812060
    iacisrmma
    Participant

    Banjobob: Proof positive. Boruch Hashem I am living and breathing and never tasted nor wanted to taste latkes with melted cheese and ketchup.

    #1812089
    dogooder
    Participant

    ketchup is the way to go

    #1812332
    Reb Eliezer
    Participant

    Tastes differ. I don’t like sour cream and like apple sauce.

    #1822097
    bobbanjoisawsome
    Participant

    Banjobob so true… so true …

Viewing 28 posts - 51 through 78 (of 78 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.