Mesivta Gemaros

Home Forums Controversial Topics Mesivta Gemaros

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1354250

    There are those that are meshabeiach the use of these gemaros. Others not so much.

    My take on it is pok chazi mai avid ama debar, what is the oilam doing. For some reason, most yeshiva gedoilahs do not carry them. The yeshiva I learn in has an extensive up to date library, but it does not include artscroll or the mesivta gemaros.

    Personally, I have benefited immensely from them. Before each zman, I pay a chashuve kolel yungerman, to learn with me the chidushim in the back, which is a tamtzis of the “Reid” on each sugya. When I learn the sugya biyun during the zman, it goes geshmirt.

    I’m told that there are others who do the same, but its begeder halacha vain morin kain.

    Bkitzur, hachaham einav brosho; chap arain before the zman!

    Signed
    Hoping to get into Brisk

    #1354514

    If you are hoping for brisk, you should stick to the rashba and the rambam

    #1354520
    iacisrmma
    Participant

    Hoping..:Is it possible to explain what you are posting…..in english?

    #1354554
    Harotzehbilumshmo
    Participant

    iacisrmma: It is understandable for those familiar with yeshiva talk. Its an intentional exaggeration of typical lingo among yeshiva students

    #1354562

    az men darf mazbir zain., toig nisht

    #1354659
    Geordie613
    Participant

    If you’re hoping for Brisk, you should know, der Rov volt kein mol niet azei getohn.
    Stop being lazy and horeveh oif der sugyah!
    Hatzlocheh Rabbeh

    #1354658
    iacisrmma
    Participant

    Horotzeh…: Ich veis “yeshiva redd”….This though makes no sense even to me!

    #1354718
    ubiquitin
    Participant

    “Horotzeh…: Ich veis “yeshiva redd”….This though makes no sense even to me!”

    elah mai….

    #1354909

    How is using mesivta being lazy; it gives youi the mareiy mekomos

    #1354918
    YW Moderator-25
    Moderator

    How is using mesivta being lazy; it gives youi the mareiy mekomos

    It’s kinda like responding to your own posts using a different username.

    #1354933

    the post is from Hoping for Brisk, not from me

    Right

    #1354930
    Geordie613
    Participant

    How is using mesivta being lazy; it gives youi the mareiy mekomos

    Mesivta (and Artscroll) is not meant for bnei torah who learn all day. When I said lazy, I meant for a Yeshiva-man who is learning all day, not a baalabos (like me) who has only a few hours a day to learn. Btw, I use a talman shas (if you know what that is…) and still think that is too modern, coz it has bold diburei hamaschil in Rashi.

    #1356395
    Harotzehbilumshmo
    Participant

    iacisrmma: Actually makes perfect sense, although intentionally exaggerated

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.