Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › R Mintz asking R Soloveitchik
- This topic has 5 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 2 weeks ago by Always_Ask_Questions.
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 29, 2026 12:26 pm at 12:26 pm #2579108Always_Ask_QuestionsParticipant
this is just a small, very biased to hot topics, excerpt:
q: should yeshiva spend more energy on talented students so they become gadol bTorah or equally on everyone
a: mistaken question, who said talented students will become gadol bTorah, those who work harder and want it more, will!q: is it ok to tell ever student that he can become gadol hador
a: MUST say so!
… Today there is so much learning, hundreds of yeshivos with thousands of students bu very little anashim gedolim
q: but there are many who know shas and poskim!
a: they are anashim hashuvim meod, but not gedolimq: why in EY, they do not learn without money?
a: today everything is for money, from lo lishma will come lishma
up to 200 years ago, ever Jew was observant. it was onl a question – to go learn or to learn profession and live life of Torah and mitzvos
…
rambam was expert in whole Torah and science when he was young and so was Gra by age of 20.q: can you write a letter explaining how to learn the right way, maybe yeshivos will listen to you?
a: am haaretz is always louder than talmid chochom
…
today everyone wants to be “frum” – tikun hatzos, peos from age 3, asking for brochos, instead of actually learning
…
q on girl education
a: in europe, fathers and sons went to admor, and women went to theater, good girls would not marry students, only old and disfigured ones, and later even they did not wantq: was there a machlokes in Volozhin between beis Halevi and Netziv?
a: no, they had different derech but respected each other, only their chasidim had machlokes. At those times, gedolim respected each other, not like nowq: Zionists in Brisk
a: there was a letter sent around to support keren kayemet lisrael signed by 50 rabbis, including an important rav from Vilno whom I knew personall, he was ver ehrliche and eydel and full of eras shamayim.q: how to explain that Jews in Europe became non-religious so quickly?
a: yetzer hara of the generation (R Ashi v Menashe Sanhedrin 102)
Maharil Diskin was fighting haskala openly in Brisk and lost his position. Beis Halevi was opposing them smarter and was more successfulq: R Feinstein told me that in Europe there were problems with shehitah, leading to tumtum lev that lead to people abandoning Torah
a: maybe in Russia, in Brisk there were no problems with shehitah, but same thing happened, although there is a sor about Rambam where he makes such connection.q: I heard from R Kornglass that R Chaim Brisker was known in Brisk as “Rav Haimke” because he did so much chesed, not for his learning
a: everone could come into his house and sleep even when there was no place for household members. His books were taken one by one from the bookshelf, and then bookshelf also because it was empty anyway
..
Beis Halevi was poor, all Litvishe rabonim were, some were selling shabbos candles, or were charging rich merchants for din Torah, children were going to beis sefer without shoes, but they were happy like rich families – the worked hard and then went to shul to daven, hear shiur, say tehilim,q: what was Brisk position about kiruv? people say they are against, but there is Rambam on how important it is …
a: not so, 99% what you hear about Brisk is not truth. Those who are capable should be doing it!q: but some say it will affect the person negatively
a: foolish! every person should check himself, and if he won’t be affected, he should do itq: we have learning by phone but hard to find bnei Torah to participste
a: a very good thing to doAugust 1, 2026 5:52 pm at 5:52 pm #2580487HaKatanParticipantRabbi Dr. Soloveichik espoused heretical views (see Rav Shach and others), so his opinions aren’t all that relevant to Orthodox Jews, only to his sycophantic followers who laughingly misappropriated the Brisker Rav’s title (with a kamatz) and shortened it to simply “The Rav” (with a Zionist patach) and applied that to their Rabbi Dr.
“q: Zionists in Brisk
a: there was a letter sent around to support keren kayemet lisrael signed by 50 rabbis, including an important rav from Vilno whom I knew personall, he was ver ehrliche and eydel and full of eras shamayim.”The very name there should cause one to vomit in disgust. The Zionist heretics purposely denied an open mishna we recite every day and instead changed that phrase “keren kayemes” to instead mean their heretical fund. That he made no mention of that is telling, though he was, of course, the head of Mizrachi (which is idolatry as per the gedolim) in America, so that’s no surprise.
August 1, 2026 5:52 pm at 5:52 pm #2580626yeshivaman613Participantwoah this is gold can I ask where this is printed and how i can access it?
August 1, 2026 5:53 pm at 5:53 pm #25806631a2b3cParticipantWho is R Mintz? Which R Soloveitchik?
August 3, 2026 6:55 am at 6:55 am #2581803amiricanyeshivishParticipantMy guess is it is Harav Chaim Mintz Shlita asking Harav Dovid Soloveichik Zatzal, as I know he had a lot of correspondence with him. But I may be wrong.
August 3, 2026 10:04 am at 10:04 am #2581956Always_Ask_QuestionsParticipantamiricanyeshivish gets the prize! abc123 gets the 2nd prize! Someone else responded as expected…
Sorry for pulling your leg. And m apologize to T’Ch, I had to omit the context a little so it will not be too obvious. This is actually from a personal meeting between Harav Chaim Mintz Shlita and Harav Dovid Soloveichik Zatzal. The reason I wrote this way because I was struck how similar two ver different RR Soloveitchiks are in their style – analytical, witty, caring for big picture of Am Isroel, not afraid to say things that may upset some, despite obvious differences in hashkafa! I wonder how would a yeshiva look if it were to follow both of them 🙂 Maybe, as Steipler suggests, one department – Toirah only, another – with academics (like Rabban Gamliel did – 1000 learnt Torah, and 1000 learnt Greek – I would think the later had some Torah also) ..
HaRav DS brought the story of 50 rabbis signing this letter to demonstrate how bad things were that even T’Ch got carried away b yetzer hara of zionism (his words, not mine). Out of respect, he does not name the Rabbi whom he knew personally. His other story shows how bitter, even silly, the arguments became: at a meeting with Polish politicians in Brisk (mabe in memory of Pilsudsky), Polish anthem was played [Poles were very sensitive as they just restored their independence. Everyone got up. Zionists conspired to play haTikva right after that while everyone was standing! Brisker Rav immediately sat down, and Poles saw him and also sat down (they had no clue what is happening, just tried not to offend the non-Polish speaking Yidden) and then others did too! -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.