- This topic has 17 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 5 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
When people used to wear tefillin all day, did they remove them before mussaf on rosh chodesh?
Mussaf can be said all day. Did they daven Mussaf at the end of the day?
No
I recall that my one-time Rosh Yeshivah, Rabbi Chaim Pinchas Sheinberg z”l, used to remove them for Mussaf (he always davened from the omud) and then put them back on again afterwards.
To Meno: I just have to ask….what made you think about starting a thread on this somewhat arcane question that is relevant maybe 10 times a year (given the typically a few days rosh chodesh may be on Shabbos)
Meno just started wearing tefillin a whole day.
How many eruv tavshilin threads are there?
Does that include the eruv chatzeros and eruv rav threads which I bumped before Yom Tov?
RichardMParticipant
I recall that my one-time Rosh Yeshivah, Rabbi Chaim Pinchas Sheinberg z”l, used to remove them for Mussaf.—————————
Please explain what a” one-time rosh yeshiva” is?to Gadolhadroah
I have to ask why are you such a stickler for what should or shouldn’t be discussed. there are several threads which you dismiss as the most pressing issue?Do you think YWN is only for pressing issues?
not all threads have to be as earth shattering asa “yetzer harah defense”Meno finds in interesting. nu nu. You dont, thats fine to there is no law that requires your comment why does it bother you?
Joseph,
Mussaf can be said all day.
ר’ הודה אומר עד ז׳ שעות
“Please explain what a” one-time rosh yeshiva” is?”
Wasnt directed to me. But I hope I can help
“One-time” = Former
“rosh yeshiva” = Head of the academyThus ” one-time rosh yeshiva” = His former Head of Academy
(Could also mean The head of his former academy or the Former head of his academy was that your source of confusion? The former is the most likelyI’m glad this thread was started. I’ve always wondered how we got to the point where one “must” remove tefillin before musaf when people once kept them on all day.
The minhag to take off tefillin for mussaf started huindreds of years after people stopped wearing tefillin all day.
GH: Maybe Meno was learning Mesechta Eruvin where wearing/not wearing tefillin on Shabbos is discussed.
I understand the question but was curious as to how or why the issue would arise in modern times when wearing tfillin all day is not common even among most gadolim…threads on eruv tavshllin are a bit more relevant to poishete yidden since they deal with it several time a year. Was not meant to be critical or negative….
You don’t learn or speak about the Beis HaMikdash or other halachic and Talmudical topics that we aren’t fortunate enough to be able to engage in today?
GH: The issue can come up in modern times as follows: the bris milah of someone’s son is taking place on Rosh Chodesh. Since we usually make the bris right after davening in the morning, it is customary for the Avi Haben and the Sandek to wear their tefilin. Does the Avi Haben and the Sandek put their tefilin back on after musaf for the bris? I personally was told not to while my friends son-in-law was told to put his tefilin back on.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.