Search
Close this search box.

Netanyahu Considers Allowing ‘Mixed Minyan’ Area At Kosel


koselIsraeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is to consider liberalizing access to the Kosel, officials said on Wednesday, citing concern that police-enforced Orthodox controls on women worshippers alienate Jews abroad.

A compromise proposed by a Netanyahu envoy would expand the Kosel plaza, to add a mixed-gender section for “other denominations of Judaism”.

The plan poses risks for Netanyahu: further alienation of Charedi Jews, whose representatives have been excluded from his new government, and a possible backlash by Palestinians against changes at the site, below the al-Aqsa mosque compound.

The envoy, former Israeli cabinet minister Natan Sharansky, sought backing for the idea from “Jewish leaders” in the United States this week and would present it to Netanyahu upon his return, officials said.

The rift has been laid bare by a group called “Women of the Wall”, which includes Americans, and whose monthly attempts to conduct monthly “Minyanim” at the site have brought a police crackdown.

Netanyahu, a secular right-winger, is wary of losing diaspora support for Israel at a time of mounting international pressure over its stalled peacemaking with the Palestinians, an official briefed on Sharansky’s mission told Reuters.

“There is no doubt that’s why Netanyahu asked Sharansky to find a compromise,” said the official, who asked not to be identified before the proposal was formally announced.

NO DIGS

Sharansky proposes converting an old archaeological dig south of the Wall to a new enclosure which would be connected to the current prayer plazas but where men and women would be allowed to mix and worship freely.

“There has been no archeological activity there in a long time, so my recommendation is to regard the entire expanse as a place for Jews to pray in,” Sharansky told the Ynet news site.

The plan would not entail structural damage around al Aqsa, Islam’s third-holiest shrine, Sharansky said. Palestinian fears of Israeli incursions there have sparked violence in the past.

Sharansky, who heads the quasi-governmental Jewish Agency for Israel, said he presented the plan to “Jewish leaders” of the various denominations in Israel and the United States, and to Israeli cabinet ministers.

“Everyone has their misgivings but they all understand that the situation where the Western Wall is a place of division must end, and that it must be rebuilt as a unifying place,” he said.

Peggy Cidor, a member of the Women of the Wall’s board of directors, said the plan “sounds very, very encouraging”.

“This situation, where every month we see one, two or three women being detained by police (at the Wall), could not go on,” she told Israel’s Army Radio. “That was clear to everyone.”

(Reuters)



7 Responses

  1. Return the Kotel to the status it had prior to 1948: A place exclusively for private reflection rather than public prayer.

  2. What’s next? Communal bathrooms as well? This is a place of historical worship. If these women choose to follow another distorted route then fine but dot impose it on the whole world. You don’t see gay Muslims complaining to open a section in their mosques; they just won’t have it. Besides, imagine the hillul Hashem that will eventually spill over when the ultra orthodox stand at the new entrance spitting and cursing…real compromise then….

  3. there is no estrangement from diaspora jews… the problem is they will use it ass a launching pad to espouse ideas contrary to judaism to the thousands of kids and soldiers and say dont go to the orthodox you can go to the kotel and be jewish our way next the messianic jews are going to want a spot to pray and dance with rabbi jesus!!

  4. Unity is unity and Halacha is Halacha no matter what! Halacha is mandated by the Torah, NOT human emotions! No wonder her name is Peggy Cidor. A pig tries to make itself look kosher to the public by showing its split hoves. Her name really should be Piggy Cidor. Piggy Cidor probably thinks, “Since one yesod of Judaism is that there should be unity, so, if there is a mixed minyan there will be even more unity! Piggy Cidor thinks like a sly/ sniky pig.

  5. We really don’t need the politicians or the rabbonnim setting rules for who may daven, where they can stand/sit, what they can wear, what kind of davening can be done in the ezras nahsim, etc. The main plaza in front of the kosel already looks like a bazaar with all sorts of chairs, shtenders, bimahs etc. strewn about with no organization or guidelines. As Charlie Hall so elegantly stated in Post no. 2, lets revert back to the concept of the kosel as a place for quiet reflection and personal prayer with no formal minyanim and no need for Rabinovich et. al. to be making up new rules every other day

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts