MAILBAG: FIVE DAYS OF SEMINARY. WEEKS OF CHAOS; Is This Really How We Want A Bas Yisroel To Spend Yom Tov?

LET’S PUT THINGS IN PERSPECTIVE: IT’S TIME TO RETHINK THE SEMINARY CALENDAR.

This article is not about bashing seminaries, debating whether they should exist, or criticizing their pricing. Girls are going to seminary, and we need to make the system work better for them.

There is a real issue that deserves attention.

Think About What We Are Asking of These Girls
Imagine being a 17- or 18-year-old girl traveling 5,000 miles away from home, entering a completely new country, school, and social environment, and trying to find your place.

And then, within the first week, comes Rosh Hashana.

Suddenly, she must figure out where to daven, whether she needs to buy a seat, where she will eat, who she will be with, and how she will get there. Some seminaries are far from the areas where these arrangements are available, forcing girls to pack up and relocate almost as soon as they arrive.

A few days later comes Yom Kippur, followed by Sukkos and an entire week of additional arrangements.

These girls are eating meals with people they barely know, often in environments very different from the homes they grew up in. While many families graciously open their homes, not every arrangement is appropriate. Some girls find themselves at meals with large groups of bochurim, sometimes even intoxicated bochurim. Others are forced to rent apartments because their seminaries close for all seven days of Sukkos.

Think about that. An 18-year-old girl has just arrived in a foreign country and is expected to navigate all of this on her own, before she has even had a chance to settle in.

Meanwhile, she is still trying to make friends, get to know her teachers, adjust to a new environment.

Is this really how we want a bas Yisroel to spend her Yom Tov going from meal to meal, eating in places she doesn’t belong, and wandering the streets of Eretz Yisroel late at night?

Does This Really Make Sense?
We send girls 5,000 miles from home for five days of school, only to leave them to fend for themselves through weeks of Yom Tov.

Is that really the best way to structure the year?

This is not about blaming any one seminary, family, or host. It is about recognizing that the system creates an unnecessary burden during what is already a major life transition.

We can do better.

There Is a Practical Solution
What if the official seminary year simply began two days after Sukkos?

Parents who want their daughters to experience Sukkos in Eretz Yisroel could still arrange for them to arrive early and stay with relatives or trusted friends. But girls would no longer be expected to navigate the entire Yom Tov season immediately upon arrival as part of their seminary schedule.

For everyone else, this would eliminate an enormous amount of unnecessary pressure.

And what about the lost school days? Seminaries could extend the school year by approximately two weeks at the end. They could also consider starting the learning before the girls arrive in Eretz Yisroel, with a staff member flying to America to give a few introductory classes, supplemented by Zoom classes to help the girls get into the proper Yom Tov atmosphere.

Instead of rushing into five days of school followed by weeks of uncertainty, the girls could begin their seminary experience when they are settled and ready to benefit from it.

This is not a complicated proposal. It is a practical adjustment that could make a meaningful difference.

The Conversation We Need to Have

We need to ask ourselves honestly: Is this really how we want our daughters to spend Yom Tov?

We should not be afraid to reconsider a schedule simply because it is what we have always done.

Sometimes, the answer is simple: It’s time to rethink the system.

Let’s put things in perspective. Let’s make seminary make sense for the girls.

Moshe Dovid Perlstein – Lakewood

The views expressed in this letter are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of YWN. Have an opinion you would like to share? Send it to us for review.

(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)

31 Responses

  1. It’s uiitter insanity. these guirls are begging like snororers to find places to sleep and est…. and all I hear is “this makes them mature”

    So lets spend 35K a year on my daughter being a shnonorer because it will make her “mature”.

    This entire thing is so sick that it’s even SICKER to discuss it anymore.

  2. It toughens them up. The schools know what’s best for these girls. Stop mixing in with your two cents. Just listen blindly and follow instructions.

  3. Of course it doesn’t make any sense. I’m not sure what you were thinking. The solution is STOP SENDING TO SEMINARY!!!! especially to Israel. And stop listening to all the stupid advice from random people about maturity and growing up or getting ready for marriage or all that stuff is all garbage. It’s about the seminaries making money. Full stop.

  4. Another, potentially better, proposal would be for seminary to start several weeks EARLIER, maybe in July. And end BEFORE Pesach!! So maybe we can save parents thousands of dollars not having to fly them home for Pesach because “everyone” now comes home Pesach. Oh, but that would interfere with the heilige seminary staffs Bein Hazmanim trips!!! Whoa, now that’s a BIG problem!
    Scratch that. We’ll just have to make the girls more “mature”. And the parents lose more money and more sleep. In the name of the heilige “growth” our daughters so desperately need.

  5. Considering that we’re spending nearly 40 grand, seminaries should be open the entire yuntif and offer meals. What we let them get away with as paying customers is unreal.

  6. The system here was also insanity with boys starting yeshiva 3 weeks before their sister’s because of “elul”. Parents had nothing to do with their daughters at all who were wandering pizza shops all day and 7-11. Where is the leadership

  7. Yes. That’s how they will become independent instead of us spoon-feeding our children until they are 30.

    Let them learn to be independent. You’ll be surprised how capable they are if you’d only give them the chance.
    Unfortunately you aren’t giving the the chance to be independent of your constantly over shadowing and worrying about them. Worrying? Take out a tehillim. But let them learn their independence.

    And yes, there are a select few who aren’t capable – those few shouldn’t be sent to EY.

  8. It can be a rushed adjustment. But no one really goes to seminary because they want to do more homework and take more tests. They go for the experience and that’s a part of it. Succos in E’Y is beautiful. There’s usually an Eim Habait or Madrichot to help them out and it’s not harder to make new friends when out for meals together than it is in class. Some sems invite the girls who don’t have family there to go to the teachers’ houses for the meals. They can get to know their teachers in a comfortable setting around their kids and in their kitchens. I would agree that seminary girls being invited to a meal with a group of buchorim is bizzare. I never heard of that happening when I was in Seminary. In the end, these somewhat awkward meals as they get to know each other and the country and going up and down the hills as they walk to and from them are a part of the memories that stay with them years later.

  9. What? Parents send their daughters to Eretz Yisroel without a plan? Guess what. Rosh Hashana, Yom Kippur, and Sukkos are completely predictable. They happen every year, abd anyone with enough intellect to read a calendar can know exactly when they will be. Same goes for Shabbos. Before committing to the year in Israel, have some plans. They can involve relatives, the seminary staff, whatever. Planning poorly, then complaining is foolish. Grow up.

    And I’ll join the plug against seminary in Israel as a necessity. It’s a luxury, and should never be the standard.

  10. That might work this year because the chaggim were early. But years it starts later thats not practical. Imo a better solution would be for the sems to be open for the chaggim. They could charge extra to stay there, but it should at least be an option. Or if they arent able to have minyanim in their location (because they are remotely located and no walkable minyanim) offer a shabbaton in a different location for an extra charge. Theres also the issue not mentioned about girls who hold two days of chag (probably most of them). It is very hard to find somewhere for them to stay for both days.

  11. I was never a seminary girl and I’ll never be one. I was a Yeshiva Bochur back in the day and I traveled from Yeshiva in Telz Stone to Har Nof where I stayed with my Grandparents and cousin. Perhaps with my setup I was lucky but maybe I never properly matured because I didn’t have a question of where I would be for Sukkos and Simchas Torah. I think I did mature a bit when in error on the first day of sukkos I took my Grandfathers Hadasim and Aravos. Apparently he went out of his way to get very special I ones. I felt terrible but got over it. I also matured when during chol homoade, I went to the Western wall, and there was an attack at the wall with rocks being thrown over. I ran up to the old city and from the soldiers throwing tear gas, I had tear gas in my eyes. And that was a very big experience for me. I remember rushing to purchase a seltzer and washing my eyes out. A guten vinter!

  12. It is exceptionally rare for a seminary girl to be left without a place to go. Every seminary I have ever interacted with will help place their students. I’m not doubting that it happened, but I have never heard of a seminary girl being “forced” to rent an apartment.

    Furthermore, there is no reason for a seminary girl to pay for a seat in a shul. This is an American practice that isn’t the norm in Israel. I have been here for about 20 years, only ever saw it in a very American shul.

    There are so many organizations that help place students. And so many hundreds, if not thousands of families that host. Yom Tov is a beautiful time to be in Israel. Increasingly, most “yeshivish” seminaries are insisting on their girls being in Sem for all of Chol Hamoed, giving them only one day off. They have tiyulim every day. It’s a blast.

    I don’t work in a Sem, but we have seminary girls over very regularly. Unless they are cousins or siblings (the guests are family) very few people will mix genders.

    I’m sure there are horror stories, but the seminaries we host from (spanning the more modern through the strictest) will even call us if they don’t know us, to confirm that the standards and “avirah” of the host is appropriate for their students.

  13. Seminaries are a business with steady high demand and they have all the leverage.
    Their marketers are the American high school morahs and principals. Until that changes nothing else will.

  14. Rabbi Perlstein: Maybe be the trailblazer to start Seminary after Sukkos. You have the Seminary, the students clamoring to get in and the pleitzes to do it.

  15. Reb Moshe Duvid, you are 100% correct, the only question is why are you posting this on YWN, you have all the important peoples numbers…
    Next time Rav Malkiel Shlit”a calls you to get a girl or boy into your camp, school or mesivta, ask them this question…

  16. The continued decline of the dollar relative to the shekel will make seminary ultimately unaffordable for many frum people. This market may collapse within the coming decade if adjustments aren’t made to lower costs for families.

  17. I think we should make it that all post HS, boys and girls study in joint sems/yeshivas that have campuses in both countries. from Sukkos until Purim in Israel and from Pesah until Sukkos in America. This way no one can ever learn a productive word because their all busy adapting
    Wont that teach them some maturity?

  18. Seminary is worth $5k TOPS, and is INCLUDING being open every shabbos and yomtov with full meals..

    That’s it.

    והשיב את הגזילה אשר גזל

  19. jdb – In the shuls I know here in E”Y, it is the norm to charge for seats on Yomim Noraim.
    That said, I think most girls either have relatives to go to or go along with a friend who has relatives. It could be that some girls fall between the cracks – no relatives and no good friends to come along with – but that is not typical. It’s true seminary girls haven’t had a chance to make new friends when school starts right before Rosh Hashana – usually right before an ibbur yahr (Jewish leap year). But who says that yomtov arrangements have to be made with new friends? Most girls have “old” friends from their hometown who also came to sem in Israel – whether in the same sem or not. Piggybacking with a friend who has relatives or family friends for yomtov hosting can be arranged even before they come to Israel. Again, there may be some very shy girls who have a hard time with this, and perhaps a year in Israel is not ideal for her, unless she overcomes her reticence and learns to fend for herself – good life skills to develop, if she’s able to handle it. It can make her, but don’t let it break her!

  20. I don’t even know what the argument is, the amount people are paying for this absurdity makes it completely obnoxious to abandon the girls for the holiday when they just showed up to the country. Have an optional program or something. Or leave the door open so they can sleep and eat nearby. Don’t lock them to the streets like dogs when they’re paying over 30 grand for 8 months

  21. @TorahJewfromNY shnoring isn’t independence. It’s one thing if the girls were cooking up their own yuntif, but that isn’t an option

  22. Everybody keeps on complaining about the seminary crisis. I read about it on Jewish websites and magazines, though I don’t think any change ever comes of it. B”H my daughter is in a chasidishe brooklyn high school where 99% of the grade doesn’t attend seminary. Why would I want to spend another $30,000 on one year when I can barely pay the high school tuition? And what exactly are the girls learning that they haven’t learned yet in the last 12 years they were in school? Besides knocking on strangers‘s door to beg to eat a yt meal

  23. 2 days before Rosh Hashana, my friend and I had nowhere to go. An Israeli girl at a mall ended up inviting us. She was the only one in her family who spoke a little English. It was a 3 day YT. This was 13 years ago.

  24. The seminaries are set up in a way that is degrading and unrefined. Face it, you are sending your daughters to shnorr for meals, or even ask rachmanus to sleep in someone’s house for shabbos. If the seminary offers meals, the girls still feel like they are nebach and not so with it if they don’t find a place to go. And if you shnorr a place also to sleep then you are really learning good life skills. Kol hakovod! By the way, most people living in Israel look at the seminary girls and say “What is this supposed to be?? What are their parents thinking??”

  25. Thank you for this letter. I don’t know that this is the correct address. We need to make more “noise”. We live in EY and receive many calls from random sem girls who need a place. To have them is inconvenient (my kids have to sleep on mats on the floor), expensive (here in Israel many of us barely make YT), and sometimes uncomfortable – for them and for us. The letter-writer is 100% right and it’s even worse! This is extremely inappropriate. What has happened to כלל ישראל – from הנה באהל to THIS???? We have lost all sense of what is צניעות and where a woman belongs. We are not feminists and we don’t have to do this… the people who run the seminaries have clouded judgement, if any. They are making lots of money on this. If they are open they have to have the girls stay there unless they have special permission to go to aunts/uncles/grandparents – if the conditions are satisfactory.

    I wanted to take my 10th grade daughter to Lakewood with me for a wedding. The principal asked lots of questions before giving permission even though she would be with me and visiting my sister.

    There are no standards anymore. You send your daughter to seminary because “you have to”, spend money you don’t even have, and then the seminary doesn’t even host them… and they allow her to be hefker.
    I can go on forever… it’s a mess. I live here. I know.

  26. As one of the families that graciously hosts these girls and with 2 granddaughters in seminary this year, I found this article interesting and puzzling. Substitute the word seminary for marriage, this system expects these girls to do something much more important and complex in just 9-12 months. If they can’t deal with finding a place for Yom Tov, how do you expect them to find a husband and build a life?

  27. Simple solution! Some great entrepreneur should court seminarie students and/or their parents and charge $1,000/day and make all the arrangements for the girls! I’m sure he’ll make a killing! He may even need to higher staff to help. As it is, you pay someone to bring bedding for these primadona JAPs; why not extend it to this!
    This whole seminary year in Israel thing is stupid. Just add to the stupidity.

Leave a Reply

Popular Posts