Violent clashes erupted Thursday afternoon near Bnei Brak as Israeli police used stun grenades and physical force to disperse thousands of Chareidi protesters demonstrating against the arrest of a yeshiva bochur, leaving at least 10 people reportedly injured, several with head wounds.
The demonstration, organized by the Peleg Yerushalmi faction, brought traffic on Highway 4 to a standstill, with authorities closing the major roadway in both directions between the Aluf Sadeh and Em HaMoshavot interchanges.
Disturbing footage circulating from the scene showed injured protesters lying on the pavement, some bleeding heavily, as police attempted to clear the highway.
At least 10 protesters were evacuated to hospitals, including individuals suffering head injuries. Earlier reports from Channel 12 confirmed at least four hospitalizations.
Police deployed stun grenades during the confrontations, with videos showing explosions near groups of demonstrators and officers physically confronting protesters.
The protest was organized following last week’s arrest of yeshiva bochur Alon Smadja, a talmid at Yeshivas Tiferes Shraga in Yerushalayim.
According to Chareidi media reports, Smadja was arrested at his home in the Bayit Vegan neighborhood after military police allegedly contacted him under the pretense that a delivery was waiting outside his building. When he came downstairs, officers arrested him.
The demonstration was held under the direction of HaRav Tzvi Friedman, amid additional concerns within the Peleg Yerushalmi community regarding possible arrests of yeshiva bochurim over military enlistment.
As the protest intensified, police declared the gathering unlawful and ordered demonstrators to clear the roadway.
Officers subsequently began dispersing the crowds, using stun grenades and other crowd-control measures.
United Torah Judaism chairman MK Yaakov Asher issued a sharp condemnation of the police response, saying that although he opposes blocking highways, the images emerging from the demonstration were unacceptable.
Asher specifically pointed to footage showing injured protesters, including a bochur with special needs, lying on the ground covered in blood.
He demanded that Israel Police Commissioner Danny Levy immediately summon the officers involved for disciplinary hearings, accusing them of crossing a red line through excessive violence.
Representatives of Peleg Yerushalmi also condemned the police response, accusing National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir of using law enforcement to retaliate against Chareidim following the election results.
Meanwhile, police presented a different account of the confrontations, accusing demonstrators of refusing repeated orders to disperse and throwing stones at officers.
According to an official police statement, one officer sustained a head injury after being struck by a rock thrown during the disturbances.
Police said an officer at the scene had formally declared the demonstration illegal after attempts at dialogue failed.
Authorities emphasized that while the right to protest is protected, demonstrations cannot endanger public safety or prevent motorists from using major roadways.
Additional traffic disruptions were reported along Jabotinsky Road in Petach Tikvah, with police directing drivers to alternate routes.
(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)
32 Responses
I lived for a number of years right near Bnei Brak and took Kvish 4 to work every day. All I can say is that the police did what needed to be done and if I was being blocked I probably would have done worse with whatever tools I had in my car to get them out of the way.
What Chutzpa these people have thinking that they can just block roads.
And people keep trying to convince Lakewood guys to make Aliya, why should they leave freedom for this
Yeshivahguy1 YOU ARE NOT A YESHIVAH GUY YOU ARE A SELF HATEING JEW.
Note this is happpening under netanyahu govermant and this is not the first time he is not a freind of ours he is a foe and a liar.
כאשר יענו אותם כן יפרוץ וכן ירבה
How dare you call yourself “yeshivaguy” when you say you would have severely injured or done worse to these peaceful protestors? What would you have done to these innocent non-violent yeshiva bochurim?? Beat them unconscious? Worse? You must be an iranian or russian troll.
YWN: I thought this is in Iran—can you confirm if this is in Israel?
yeshivaguy1: Why call yourself Yeshiva!!!
Yeshivaguy1, you re completely correct. These animals don’t work and have no idea what trouble blocking traffic does. In addition to delaying people traveling to work, they slow down emergency vehicles of every sort.
@Yeshivaguy1 “the police did what needed to be done and if I was being blocked I probably would have done worse with whatever tools I had in my car to get them out of the way”.
How can you talk in such a way? Are you takeh a yid? What are the 3 traits all yidden have again? O I must have forgotten the merciful part, whoops.
How dare you threaten our brothers, whether they are right or wrong. To decide that they are wrong is your own decision, but to use it to threaten and agree with the police’s handling is so disgusting. Your comments actually should be taken down from this platform.
They are not peaceful protesters. They are law breaking hooligans who close major roads, endanger others’ lives, inconvenience hundreds of people, and are an embarrassment to Torah values especially bein adam l’chavero. Once the police declared the protest illegal and the hooligans didn’t leave, they deserved to bear the brunt of police actions. What did they think would happen if they disobeyed police orders? In a democracy, everyone has the right to protest in a legal way and no one has the right to protest illegally.
Genius…. if all of Lakewood made aliya we can have majority charedim in the holy land and they would be listening to us a lot more…
I actually live in Lakewood (and aliya currently doesn’t work for my personal situation), and it appalling how people speak about Eretz Yisroel. Somewhere that we thank hashem for every time we put a piece of bread in our mouth, we call the eretz chemda tova rechava, all our gedolim yearned to live in, and people are mezalzel and invest billions into chutz learetz.
Sad that the erev rav is everywhere , in the police force, on ywn etc. It’s up to Hashem to get rid of them
“What’s a little traffic?” you say.
Imagine a bunch of Neturei Karta guys kept blocking Route 9 in Lakewood or Route 59 in Monsey every week for a full morning right when you were trying to get your kids to school or get to work. Believe me, after the second or third time, you would feel like I do. It is very easy to think “no big deal” when you are not affected. I lived there for many years and understand what blocking Kvish 4 at that intersection does. It shuts down the whole area. That means people on the way to doctors offices, work, the hospital, emergencies, school etc.
If they won’t move and especially if they are throwing stones, you do what it takes to move them.
I fully support blocking roads! Although at first glance it may seem inappropriate, it is the only thing that actually WORKS. There is a reason why people from every single sector do it when they are upset- because it is the only thing that actually produces results! Just standing on the side of the road with a sign won’t accomplish anything…
I (as an Agudist/Zionist) have a serious question.
If the idea of YES joining the government in order to make things work for Torah and Shomrei Torah etc, why can’t all the Frum MK’s collectively do something about this? Whether it’s right or wrong, I NEVER witnessed this type of behavior from the police towards non Frum protesters.
this is not just a demonstration. When they close the kvish, they are doing nezek to multiple people.
Do they have a beis din permission?
Can those damaged call them to beis din?
Usually when someone hurts unknown to him people, like using bad weights in a store, the teshuva is to do something good for the community like water fountain, so there is a high chance that those damaged would use the service. So, they could clean the highway or maybe serve in the army?
They should have used live bullets. What a Chillul Hashem. Peleg should be expelled from E’Y. Between the protests (riots) almost daily, when do they actually have time to learn?? Good for nothings.
When you deliberately block the highway again and again and refuse to move, what do you expect them to do? Stand there indefinitely and politely ask you to cooperate? A word to the wise: if you physically block a highway , you risk being seriously injured. If you think this is unique to Israel look at the way the super anti-Zionist French and Spanish police treat street protestors for doing far less.
When it comes to the cause itself the protesters are right, I also vehemently oppose the drafting of Lomdei Torah. The police probably are being unnecessarily heavy-handed. But don’t those who called for and organized the protests also bear heavy responsibility?
The frum parties barely got 10% of the seats in Tuesday’s election. The Zionists got over 75%. Small minorities should not rebel against well armed majorities who are looking for an opportunity at “ethnic cleansing.” In most countries in the Middle East, any religious fanatics opposed to the government are imprisoned, executed, exiled or disappeared. And the article whines about stun grenades and some non-fatal bleeding????
What exactly is the point of these hafganos?
Has anything ever been accomplished from them?
yeshiva guy i think is right, they are blocking cars from driving where they need to go!!
they have power to control 1000 people from going where they need to go and everyone is helpless?? use force with sticks
or get run over the driving car that is coming towards them duh?
see RAMBAM, Sanhedrin, 1, halacha ONE!
there were enforcers with “sticks” and whips, to inflict pain to prevent any wrong doing!
(ordered by bais din)
blocking yidden from doing things or mitzvos or needs or whatever, is wrong, twisted, rishus, and we see its a sensible thing to stop them menacing and stealing peoples’ time and messing their live functioning up
with force!!
we’re supposed to stand there and be helpless and let them do it if talking and pulling each one out.. doesnt work?
ze lo seichel
> How can you talk in such a way? Are you takeh a yid? What are the 3 traits all yidden have again?
people are justifiably upset at rude language used by the “yeshiva” poster.
you should be similarly upset at the rude “yeshiva” students who are behaving so inappropriately. Nobody is even asking what gedolei (outside of peleg) has ruled to allow this. Your daas Torah is very selective.
time for mass aliyah
This is what happens when people don’t follow Halacha. There is not a single rational argument based on Halacha for these protests. The right wing religious Zionist/Torani world is doing just fine in the army. Rav Moshe Hillel himself acknowledged this. It’s a Milchemes Mitzvah as Rav Asher Weiss pointed out. You should either be serving or learning full time which most yeshiva guys aren’t even doing while taking Bein Hazmanim breaks. Shevet Levi according to the Rambam should not be doing that.
It’s an absolutely Chillul Hashem what the scum of Peleg have been doing. The nation has been at war. Almost every family has been affected except for in the Charedi world. The least you can do is show compassion and love. It shows an incredible lack of Midos to block the roads at this time.
Midah Kneged Midah. We wonder why we’re busy with our boys being taken hostage and so involved in Pidyun Shvuyin? Maybe it’s because we weren’t Nosei Biohel enough the last few years.
I challenge anyone to tell me even one long lasting positive thing that blocking roads has accomplished. To the contrary, it has backfired and contributed to tremendous sinat chinam.
“Unarmed Peleg protestors” – who throw rocks at the police. YWN is using the same kind of doublespeak as PA Arabs, where the definition of a “non-violent protest” is a protest where rocks are thrown, but no firearms are used to attack Israelis and Israeli forces.
Use of non-lethal force, such as stun grenades, tear gas, water cannons, and even rubber bullets, can absolutely be justified in this situation.
an Israeli Yid
I remember many years ago when there was a big Hafgana in Yerushalaim and a Police officer took a bat and he smashed the head of a Gerrer Avreich. The Rebbe from Ger told his Chassidim that it is a Matzav of
פיקוח נפש
and he told his Chassidim not to join the Hafgana.
Maybe the real Emes solution to this army draft issue is that we should make a
תענית אסתר
for 3 days.
Another option:
A few Rabbonim mentioned that any Avreich or Bachur that learns with true Hasmada (no playing with the phone) and doesn’t waist any time-a real serious dedicated learner, they will not arrest him.
Obviously, we need to add and I am sure the Rabbonim agree that we need to be
מקיים הלכות לשון הרע
—During the days of king Achav, Klal Yisroel won all the wars because no one snitched to Ezevel where the Kohanim were hiding. Believe it or not -all of Klal Yisroel got along with each other-they were not throwing shtenders at each other.
The Chasideshe groups-they didn’t have two Rebbes for each group. Each Rebbe got along with the other Rebbes-no fighting——-NO FIGHTING–
Also we need to cry to Hashem for help.
Option 1: Go to the protest-block the road and the Police Chayos might hurt someone and that person might cry from the wound and the pain and the force of the officer smashing a bat on to the body of the protester.
Option 2:
Go to the Shul and stay safe and healthy and not full of blood and to cry and cry to Hashem for help.
Both options we need to cry-but one option is to cry and not end up full of blood-but to enter the Bais Hamedrash and cry to Hashem for help.
yblkwd; yes, they have on occasion brought about the intended result, but most of all, if not for those hafgonos, the police would have been far more active in arresting Bnei Torah. Police made it clear to the court and A-G they don’t have the manpower for those protests and therefore cannot increase the arrests!
Dr Torahhater; and you have no idea what it means to want to be able to learn in Yeshiva without the threat of arrest for doing no wrong!
akuperma; religious fanatics in other countries are trying to impose their lifestyle onto the public – we are asking “to live and let live”, just leave us alone! For that we don’t deserve persecution of 1.4m 15% of the population!
הממלא חצר חבירו כדי יין וכדי שמן בעל החצר משבר ויוצא משבר ונכנס (ב”ק כח.)
The idea is to get attention because nobody here cares about the jailed Yeshiva students like them, looks like they’re getting people’s attention. Enough headaches and the government may rethink its position on arresting people that were learning and following the rabbis, definitely doing nothing certainly won’t help, as well as standing on the side of the road with signs. There’s no other way
@yeshiva1: There is no reason whatsoever to lift a hand on another jew. Whether they are right or wrong, our torah never allows us to touch a jewish person. I thing G-d is pretty responsible and can take care of them himself.
Are they dong the right thing? Maybe not.
You can be upset at them? Yes.
Can you touch them? No.
rebEmes The protests have done nothing but harm to the Charedi Oilam and you making excuses for it is a chillul hashem. Those thugs had what was coming to them. In regards to ” following the rabbis:” Rav Dov Lior towers over anyone in the Charedi Oilam by miles and it’s not even close.
@kinsler- Your AN Agudist/Zionist!!!!!!!!!!!! Chas Vichalila to think Agudah has anything to do with zionism! Read Bayos Hazman From Rav Reuven or Kovets Mammarim From Reb Elchonon or Chofetz Chaim Al Hatorah or Rav Henkin or Rav Shach- Zionism is avodah zara! if that sounds extreme then you have been severly brainwashed as this what EVERY GADOL BIYISROEL EVER said!