Search
Close this search box.

Poles Wait for FBI Chief to Apologize Over Holocaust Remarks


holObama did it, now the FBI director has done it, and each time it has caused huge offense to a U.S. ally: using language to suggest that Poles were accomplices in the Holocaust.

Poles were waiting to see if FBI director James Comey would issue an apology — something that hadn’t happened by late Monday. Polish Foreign Minister Grzegorz Schetyna said he expected him to say sorry so the matter can be settled.

Comey said last week, “In their minds, the murderers and accomplices of Germany, and Poland, and Hungary, and so many, many other places didn’t do something evil.

“They convinced themselves it was the right thing to do, the thing they had to do. That’s what people do. And that should truly frighten us.”

Comey’s comments are particularly offensive to Poles not only because they had no role in running Auschwitz and other death camps where Jews were murdered during World War II, but because they were themselves victims of the Third Reich. In all, 6 million Polish citizens were killed during the war, about half of them Jewish and the other half Christians, with many Polish priests, members of the intelligentsia and political resistance killed in Auschwitz and elsewhere.

Poland also had a committed anti-Nazi resistance movement and Polish fighters fought alongside the Allies throughout the war. Poles see themselves as heroes of the war who have never been properly recognized, making comments like Comey’s hurt even more.

Comey originally delivered the remarks on Wednesday at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in arguing for the importance of Holocaust education. The speech was adapted for an article published in The Washington Post on Thursday.

So far, there has been no reaction to Comey’s words from the government of Hungary, which did collaborate with the Nazis for most of the war.

But the Polish reaction was swift.

On Sunday, the U.S. ambassador to Poland, Stephen Mull, was called to the Foreign Ministry in a formal act of protest. Mull, a well-liked figure in Poland, went into damage-control mode.

“Saying that Poland and any other country other than Nazi Germany were responsible for the Holocaust is a mistake, is harmful and is offensive,” Mull said. “Director Comey certainly did not mean to suggest that Poland was in any way responsible for those crimes.”

In Washington, U.S. State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf later echoed that sentiment, saying that “Poles certainly bore a huge brunt of the barbarism of Nazi Germany.”

“Director Comey certainly did not intend to suggest otherwise, did not intend to suggest that Poland was in some way responsible for the Holocaust,” she said.

Polish leaders all had something to say about the controversy.

“To those who are incapable of presenting the historic truth in an honest way, I want to say that Poland was not a perpetrator but a victim of World War II,” Prime Minister Ewa Kopacz said Sunday. “I would expect full historical knowledge from officials who speak on the matter.”

Not all Poles behaved heroically during the war. Anti-Semitism was deep in the 1930s and some Poles pointed Jews out to the Nazis, who often could not tell Jew from non-Jew. There were also some cases of Poles murdering Jews during the war.

But collaborating was never the official state position, as it was with Vichy France, for instance. In fact, during the war, the Polish underground army had a program to save Jews, called Zegota. And Poles caught denouncing Jews to the Nazis were even killed by the Polish resistance.

President Barack Obama caused a similar controversy in 2012 when he used the wording “Polish death camp.” Poles feel that that wording implies Polish complicity, and Obama later expressed “regret” for the gaffe.

“In referring to ‘a Polish death camp’ rather than ‘a Nazi death camp in German-occupied Poland,’ I inadvertently used a phrase that has caused many Poles anguish over the years and that Poland has rightly campaigned to eliminate from public discourse around the world,” Obama wrote at the time. “I regret the error and agree that this moment is an opportunity to ensure that this and future generations know the truth.”

(AP)



12 Responses

  1. When it came to killing Jews, the Poles and Ukrainians were the biggest Nazi collaborators gleefully killing as many Jews as they could.

  2. I can’t believe that I’m seeing this AP story here.
    Let’s just rewrite history here…..the Poles had nothing to do with the Shoah(not)

  3. why should Comey apologize? the pole HATED the jews, they butchered those who came back to their homes… shouting, ‘why didn’t the germans finish their job’

  4. They’re not pleased with the truth?? So change the historical facts!! The Palestinians continually do it. See their text books and more recently their convincing of the EU nations – and it’s taking hold, sadly – as is evidenced by those 16 EU nations declaration as it relates to products from Israel. There’s also a nationality in the U.S. that has changed the facts of its history.
    So Poles, don’t like the truth about your history, change history!!

  5. 1. Germany and Hungary were members of the Axis, whose democratically elected governments entered World War II (though that of Hungary’s did engage in many acts the minimized the impact of the holocaust, which is why relatively more Hungarian Jews survived, compared to Polish Jews). Poland was a member of the Allies, and was conquered and occupied, and suffered tremendous civilian losses as well.

    2. As in most of Europe, the population overwhelming supported the “resistance” to the Nazis, by June of 1945 (and all joined the resistance retroactive to 1940).

    3. Based on many accounts, many elements of the Polish resistance helped Jews some of the time. The Boy Scouts actually helped Jews all of the time. The survival rate of Polish Jews attests to their consistency and success in such matters (cf. occupied Denmark, and Axis-member Finland).

  6. My relatives were murdered in the briker ghetto by the Poles not the nazis. Germans opened the door poles did the murdering for 3 days.

  7. Poles were complicit and had no problem killing off Jews. There are plenty of documented cases of rabid anti-Semitism, and in some cases the Nazi’s had to calm down the Polish populace.

    It’s similar to the Chazir who shows it’s hooves and says “look at how kosher I am”. Really, the Poles were far from it.

  8. Keep waiting! Mr. Comey is %100 percent right and should NEVER apologize! The Pollaks were the most vicious. Yemach Shimo Vi’zichro!

  9. The Poles were the worst anti-Semites there ever were, maybe even worst than the Germans. Almost the entire Polish people helped the Nazis and turned in Jews. Furthermore, when Jewish parents who survived, returned and asked for their children back, almost every Pole refused to return their children. Whatever bad things were said about the Poles isn’t even half of the truth about these evil people.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts