Reply To: Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky and the modern State of Israel

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky and the modern State of Israel Reply To: Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky and the modern State of Israel

#2408020
HaKatan
Participant

More Zionist nonsense.
Regarding your quote:
“The Chazon Ish encouraged people from overseas to settle in Eretz Yisrael as it is a positive commandment, and he felt that Yiddishkeit was more prevalent and easier to practice there than in the diaspora.”

So, if you would actually be a better Jew, including less of a Zionist idolater, for example, if you were to move there, then that quote would make sense. But if moving to E”Y would increase your worship of the Zionist idol (or otherwise negatively impact your Judaism), then the Chazon Ish and Rav Chaim would obviously never dream of telling you to move there.

Incidentally, the greatest halakhic decisor of the “Modern Orthodox” of today, Rabbi Herschel Schachter, also stated as above, in a lecture he gave a number of years ago in honor of the Zionists’ idolatrous “Independence Day”.

Your “PERSONAL COMMENT” also seems odd.

First, it was the Satmar Rav who was the first (publicly and in a published sefer) who “advocated for dismantling the State of Israel “peacefully”.”
He wrote that the Zionists could go to the gentiles and tell them to take over without hurting any Jews CH”V, and the gentiles would figure out a way.

You asserted, with zero basis in fact and reality:
“Even if we ignore the fact that there is NO WAY to dismantle the state without killing MILLIONS OF JEWS, dismantling the State of Israel would certainly cause MILLIONS OF JEWS to leave Eretz Yisrael permanently.”

This is, of course, false. When the Soviet Union fell overnight, it did not result in any deaths of millions, and most still stayed put exactly where they were (except the ones who wanted to leave to Western countries, which is perfectly possible now under the Zionists). There is no reason to expect differently here.