Reply To: Matzav article about Golus and Eretz Yisrael

Avnei Nezer (the Gadol HaPoskim ZTL ZYA)
clearly disagrees with Sefer VaYoel Moshe:

Avnei Nezer, chelek Yoreh Deah, siman taf nun dalet
from sif katan mem dalet and onwards [pages 287 to 289].
Now for sif katan nun in more detail:

” … and now it is good and not questionable why Rambam
[in his halacha sefer Mishneh Torah] and all poskim DID NOT
bring The Three Oaths LaHalacha, because those oaths
are not LaHalacha, because the person himself,
his body, was not commanded to keep the oaths…”

That is why the poskim DID NOT bring the oaths LaHalacha.
That is why NONE of the widely-accepted halacha sefarim mention The Three Oaths.

It is stupid to claim that The Three Oaths are “undisputed halacha”.

__________________________________________
Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman [ZTL ZYA HYD] made it perfectly clear
that his sharp criticisms were intended only for the original Zionists,
not their descendants.