Aha-I knew it! ROB, you did not look up the Michtav M’eliyahu I requested. He is writing to someone asking precisely your question.
And are we communicating at all ? I wrote in the previous thread precisely what DY wrote here. Infallibility has NOTHING to do with this conversation. As I wrote there, we all heard krias haTorah this past week.
And it is quite clear to many what was going on, and the solution not at all clear. There are very clear statements that certain Gedlom advised against emigration to America DESPITE the obvious dangers in Europe.