Reply To: Why R' Rechnitz is incorrect

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Why R' Rechnitz is incorrect Reply To: Why R' Rechnitz is incorrect

#1035718
☕ DaasYochid ☕
Participant

Popa, I don’t need hard data. I have no doubt that there’s a growing population and an age gap (typically).

I do agree, as I’ve posted, that there’s a downside. There’s also an upside: kedusha. This is in Chaza”l, and the Chazon Ish held it applied in his day, and R’ Chaim holds it applies today, so I don’t easily dismiss it.

Also, I wouldn’t necessarily expect a bima klop, because then you’d get bochurim who aren’t ready yet (l’shitaseinu) starting to go out. Maybe RY are already privately encouraging guys to start earlier.