Reply To: Why R' Rechnitz is incorrect

It is more than a sevara, and the numbers are clear, even taking into account that there are more boys than girls born (which I grant is true). and that’s without the strong anecdotal evidence if more girls around than boys.

The numbers really aren’t clear, unless you assume that the “system” gains and loses at the same rates for boys and girls–which is very much not clear.

And the anecdotal evidence could have myriads of other reasons, as I and others have expounded on this forum.

Look, bima klop or aguda convention speech, the roshei yeshiva are not lining up behind him on this. I have heard from a reliable source of a certain rosh yeshiva who does support NASI but I’m not aware that he speaks publicly on it, or that he even speaks within his yeshiva on it, which just confuses me.