gavra at work: where do yo usee from the gemoro that the geirim the gemoro mentions did not get the “benefits” of geirus, as you claim?
As far as the giyur bill- in essence, it goes back to what was always the custom: every Rov made a decision for his own community how to respond to applicants for geirus. I think it is not a good idea to have a uniform standard- life is too complicated to have “one size fits all”. That said, I think the details are important and it seems that there are various thought on this. I cannot properly jduge until one sees the actual bill.