Everyone is right, who commented on the glue traps and bags. Nevertheless, what would you suggest should be done with animals caught on glue traps? ANY trap is not humane. I could never have drowned them (as someone suggested to me once). I could not leave them in plain sight on the glue traps – it was freaking us all out (B”H this was at least a year ago). Vermin carry diseases. Would you be able to kill them quickly yourself? I couldn’t bear to, but they were infesting my home. How is a glue trap different from a roach motel, btw?
Also, poison baits make the mice very thirsty, and when they go to drink water, it makes their bellies swell up and burst. THAT’S a better idea????? I am a big proponent of avoiding tzaar baalei chayim, but health and sanity comes first.