Reply To: Paskening Hashkafa: Academic vs. Practical Rationales

Home Forums Bais Medrash Paskening Hashkafa: Academic vs. Practical Rationales Reply To: Paskening Hashkafa: Academic vs. Practical Rationales

#1042233
Joseph
Participant

“pointing out that a conclusion is not the same thing as a psak. I concluded that I typed this but I did not pasken that I typed this. The fact that Beis Shammai/Beis Hillel or the Rambam reached a conclusion on a given matter does not make it a psak. It means that they think it to be true or even that they are sure that it is true.”

Without addressing the larger disagreement but only addressing the terminology, I don’t see why pasken cannot colloquially be used in the sense of concluding.