Reply To: Remember Lipman?

DaasYochid:I must side with Patur on this.If you read the original article,you will clearly see that Rabbi Lipman was responding to an incident and he was concerned that if such incidents become more prevalent , it would prevent many people from going through a real geirus.Hence,his suggestion. As I said before, I think that there are enough ways of doing it without relying on “makilim”.Nonetheless,I appreciate Rabbi Lipman’s concerns and I think the vicious attacks o him are not warranted.