Reply To: Could Chanukah happen again

Home Forums Politics Could Chanukah happen again Reply To: Could Chanukah happen again

#1050174

To clarify my view in this discussion:

Hashem fights for our physical survival (this does not mean that

there’s no rule of “Habo l’harg’cha hashkeim l’hargo”), and we fight when He presents us with a violent challenge to our Yiddishkeit. (That’s the ideal, anyway – see Logician’s post.)

“[T]o preserve or restore Jewish sovereignty” is not something

Chareidim believe in fighting for as an ideal, and historically

speaking, lack of a Jewish government in Eretz Yisrael has not

prevented us from living there, so the country in question being

Eretz Yisrael doesn’t matter.

So, were a foreign power to give a Chareidi government,

in Eretz Yisrael or elsewhere, the option of peacefully

surrendering to them (becoming subject to foreign taxation, etc.),

I think we’d take it. Does anyone here disagree?