Sam2 -“Health: You’re wrong. Being Over on the 7 Mitzvos is not a blanket death sentence.”
No one said it was!
“It’s a Chiyuv on Beis Din (like any Misas Beis Din) to mete out.”
So what?
“It’s not a free-for-all for anyone to kill someone who was Over.”
It becomes one when the Gov. don’t keep the 7 Mitzvahs. Anyone can do it, if they can do it legally.
“We don’t do it because if we did it would be Retzicha Al Pi Halacha, not because American law won’t let us.”
You’re wrong again!
“Misas Beis Din have to be done by Beis Din, not Stam vigilantes.”
It’s Not vigilantism, when it’s Rozon Hashem!