Jothar– The ramban at the end of Keitzad haregel paskens basar tavar maneh. l`choirah your vort is a proof to rashi. The ketzos answers siman ??? that be’etzem theramban is maskim here that we go basar me’ikarah because of v’nahapach hu but by the garbage everybody is maskim tavar manah because the scarah of the gemarah for tavar manah is manah tvirah tavar– you broke a broken keli– so huh goofah garbage is a broken keli so we go tavar manah and the garbage did not land before she jumped.
the nesivos siman ??? asks l’choirah reshaim are called dead even when they are alive so why do we have such a complicate svarah of basar meikarah… he answers the svarah of v’nahapach hu makes chapui rosh before aivel ayin shum brebi akivah aiger