Reply To: theoretical question from mesechet Gitin

Home Forums Bais Medrash theoretical question from mesechet Gitin Reply To: theoretical question from mesechet Gitin

#1065203
frumnotyeshivish
Participant

The sufficiency of the nemanus of a shliach saying befanai nechtav comes from the concepts of “mishum iguna” and “meidak dayak,” of which the latter would either supersede or prevent the husband from contradicting the shliach (if my memory from many years ago serves correctly). According to those that say that should the husband contradict the shliach he would win, one could question whether that would apply to someone else as well. I think it’s popular “reid” but who knows.