Reply To: This is Not Related to the Theological Conundrum

Without the other gemaros, one might think there’s no mitzvah to learn shelo lishmah; in fact, it might be an aveirah (kardom lachpor bo).

I could possibly hear that, but then it Tosafos really should have asked from kardom. But then again, I could also hear that at least in Berachos Taanis Tosafos had no choice because those gemaros are discussing the badness of shelo lishma.