Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no › Reply To: Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no
This was the response I got from Jay karzen which seems to be slightly different from the original replies I had received.
reply
Yes, you are Jewish and Rev. Noah Wolff, acing as Mohel, is certainly qualified and accepted by all modern Orthodox Rabbis in USA…
I knew that late Rabbi Charney well and he was indeed Conservative. But the fact that Wolff did the Brit Milah on you is significant and should not change your status. You are Jewish! jkarzen
Original Message
My Sephardi friend is saying that at the Sephardic synagogues it’s not an issue. I consider myself modern orthodox. My current rabbi is a Israeli Jew of Yemenite background and he is also aware of the situation but has accepted it as valid.