Reply To: Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no

Home Forums Controversial Topics Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no Reply To: Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no

#1077300
Rav Tuv
Participant

Not sure I understand. Rev. Wolff was not at your mother’s conversion. How can he possibly have an opinion of whether she or you are Jewish? Reb Moshe Feinstein was clear that non orthodox conversions are not kosher PERIOD.

IIRC Rabbi Karzen who is from Chicago, Had a Traditional congregation. So he is also not Orthodox.

I agree with those saying you should have a geirus l’chumra ASAP and then there are no questions.