“adifferent opinions and scenarios related to this issue, and specifically about how the Agudah deals with it.”
this machlokes you created is really a machlokes in pesukim between dovid and Shlomo
Dovid said tov li toras picha mialfai zahav vichesef
Shlomo said kesef yana es hakol
we know hilchisa kibasra
so therefore Agudah paskens like Shlomo Hamelech