Simcha613,
I was not referring to that post, all I was doing there was merely pointing out the flaws of that the the fact that there are “marriages’ that cannot have children is irrelevant as to determining the general purpose of marriage.
However that is not my argument because I think the argument may be true but it’s is not intrinsic rather it is based on circumstance.
What I hold as the better argument is the one in my next post which Matan1 has not responded to.