yekke2 – your post above is beautiful but false. You are so wrong about so much of what you are writing. You speak an awesome theory, you are 100% right about what SHOULD be, but unfortunately you are wrong about real life, how things are dealt with and what actually happens. I’ve noticed the naivete in many posts on this thread and others in regard to abuse and abusers and I didn’t want to bring it up because I do not approve of the global bashing that usually follows. Please know tho that the more you insist, the more painful it is to people who lived thru it and met up with nothing resembling what you write.
— Syag
I’m sorry if anybody was offended by anything I wrote, and please feel free to argue with anything you feel is incorrect. What happens in real life that we don’t know about? What actually happens? The purpose in these threads is that people like you, who are apparently unfortunately more knowledgeable about these things than us, should come forth and write your opinion.
I’m not sure exactly which post (I’ve posted quite a few on this thread) you are arguing with. Doesn’t sound like the halachic ones… Would you care to specify which post and what you have to add to it?