Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › Zionism, Why the Big Debate? › Reply To: Zionism, Why the Big Debate?
I think it’s more clear in this quote:
“In his addresses to the American Mizrachi Association, which were subsequently transcribed as the Chamesh Derashot, the Rav explained the first aspect of this change of heart. The Rav noted that in the realm of halachah, the rabbinic majority reigns supreme. G-d gave the Torah to man and our capacity for halachic creativity and decision-making is axiomatic to a live and vibrant relationship to G-d. In hashkafah however, the rules are different. For questions that are outside
soften the blow of exile. The Rav explained that the Mizrachi of 1902 represented Yosef Hatzadik and Agudah represented the other brothers. Mizrachi wanted to reevaluate Jewish life in Europe, to prepare for the Jewish future and ensure Jewish continuity, whereas Agudah were content with the status quo. Mizrachi fought and dreamed, and without them there would have been no place for refugees to go to following the war. Without the yishuv, Hitler would have killed Judaism. The Rav saw this as a full retroactive justification of Mizrachi philosophy.”
(“The Religious Zionism of Rav Soloveitchik: A Synthesis of Worlds”
Pesach-To-Go Nissan 5773 p.67-68)